What is the climax of the novel The Great Gatsby ?

Answers

Answer 1

Answer: The climax of the novel comes when the group is driving back from New York in two cars, and Myrtle, Tom's lover, mistakes Gatsby's car for Tom's and runs out into the street and is hit and killed. The car that kills Myrtle belongs to Gatsby, but Daisy is driving. After this, the action resolves quickly.

Explanation:


Related Questions

6 Link the sentences in all possible ways using:
furthermore, in addition, moreover, what is more,
however, but, on the other hand, although.

1 People need to be informed about environmental
problems. They should be taught how to help solve
them.
2 Some people are optimistic about the future. Others
feel that life will become worse.
3 New cars will be more environmentally-friendly. They
will be easier to drive.
4 The amount of pollution given off by factories is
decreasing. The hole in the ozone layer is still growing.
5 Most people live in cities for work reasons. A lot of
them would prefer to live in the country.
6 In the future, cities may have to be protected with
shields. People will have to pay for clean air and water.

Answers

Simple addition, furthermore and forwarding an argument, and addition and advancing an argument while also noting that the new reason is of a different kind from the previously provided reasons are all examples of addition.

Is likewise a suitable transitional phrase?

These typical transitional phrases are included together with the categories to which they belong. To Add: and, and then, besides, equally crucial, lastly, further, also, nor, too, next, lastly, what's more, furthermore, additionally, first (second, etc.)

Who knows all ten conjunctive adverbs?

Accordingly, furthermore, additionally, similarly, also, hence, specifically, still, anyway, nevertheless, nonetheless, next, thereafter, unquestionably, unquestionably, further, meanwhile, therefore, consequently, instead, now, thus.

To know more about furthermore visit :-

https://brainly.com/question/16155417

#SPJ1

What does ownership mean in life?

Answers

Ownership means in life Assuming a sense of ownership with your viewpoints, and activities, and life can feel testing. It requires a readiness to gain from your slip-ups, owns your victories and disappointments, and quit faulting others for your conditions. In any case, taking responsibility for life likewise fabricates character, coarseness, and dignity.

In basic terms, taking total responsibility for implies controlling what we have some control over and being completely responsible/liable for those things (for example our decisions and the moves we make). It implies building a strong person and living with trustworthiness in any event when it's badly arranged (in addition to other things).

Learn more about ownership mean in life:

https://brainly.com/question/4696622

#SPJ4

Steve Jobs cofounded Apple Computers with Steve Wozniak in 1976, but Jobs was phased out of the company during the 1980s after it experienced major setbacks. b. Steve Jobs cofounded Apple Computers with Steve Wozniak in 1976, despite that fact, Jobs was phased out of the company during the 1980s after it experienced major setbacks. c. Steve Jobs cofounded Apple Computers with Steve Wozniak in 1976, however, Jobs was phased out of the company during the 1980s after it experienced major setbacks. d. Steve Jobs cofounded Apple Computers with Steve Wozniak in 1976, however Jobs was phased out of the company during the 1980s after it experienced major setbacks.

Answers

This question seems to be incomplete. However, there is enough information to find the right answer.

Answer:

a. Steve Jobs cofounded Apple Computers with Steve Wozniak in 1976, but Jobs was phased out of the company during the 1980s after it experienced major setbacks.

Explanation:

The only one that uses punctuation marks correctly is option a.

The first comma in option b should be a period (making the first part a simple sentence) or a semicolon that links the two independent clauses.

The same happens with the first comma in options c and d, as it should be a period or a semicolon.

Answer:

A

Explanation:

Can somebody give me a summary about echoes from the past cant be to short.



use the "literary present" to retell events


include only important events and characters


disregard minor details and irrelevant information


present events in chronological order

Answers

Leni and Gina, identical twins who have a frightening secret in common, are the subject of the mystery-thriller miniseries. They've been living double lives since they were kids, sharing two homes, two husbands, and a child in their adult lives.

What is summary of echoes?The miniseries is a mystery-thriller about identical twins Leni and Gina, who have a perilous secret in common. They have been surreptitiously switching lives since they were young, and now, as adults, they share two homes, two husbands, and a child.For the majority of the series, we are made to assume that Leni is the missing twin, but toward the end, we learn that Gina was the one posing as Leni. Traditional winery Gina was attempting to escape Leni's grip, but are either of them actually "decent" people. The understanding that the twins aren't themselves in that first episode, but have switched roles, is the first of many intricate twists in Echoes.

To learn more about echoes refer to:

https://brainly.com/question/10875037

#SPJ4

What was the result of administration under the Articles of Confederation?

Answers

The Articles provided state governments the preponderance of authority in a loose union of sovereign states with a weak central government.

Illustrative examples of articles.

The usage of an article, which is a word, designates a noun without describing it. For instance, the article a indicates that the word dog is a noun in the sentence Nick bought a dog. Articles can change pronouns, noun phrases, and anything else that functions as a noun.

Why are articles used in sentences?

There are particular modifiers known as articles that come before nouns or noun phrases. They help to elaborate on the meaning of the noun in your phrase, just like other adjectives do. There are just two articles in English: the and a.

To know more about Articles visit:

https://brainly.com/question/13359299

#SPJ4

In J.K. Rowling's "The Tale of the Three Brothers", what does the sentence "separated from him by a veil" mean?

Answers

Answer: I think it means that he was separated from his wife. I'm a Harry Potter fan so I think that's right.

Hope that helped! :)

Explanation:

Which of these phrases are examples of personification.A she is falling through cracks.B.The wind spoke in song.C. Her hair was like a sea of spaghetti

Answers

Answer:

The wind spoke in song

Explanation:

personification is when you give a none living object person like task

What is the topic sentence in this paragraph?
Alexander Hamilton’s major role in the US government was secretary of the Treasury. He used his position to generate income to strengthen the federal government’s power. After the Revolutionary War, the new government needed a way to pay its debts, and Hamilton created several plans to make this happen. One plan involved a tax on luxury goods. Another included buying and selling bonds to private investors. Hamilton wanted to establish a national banking system using one currency, which would help bring the states together as one nation.

Answers

The topic sentence in the given paragraph is Alexander Hamilton.

Who was Alexander Hamilton?

American revolutionary, politician, and one of the country's founding fathers, Alexander Hamilton. In addition to founding the Federalist Party, the country's financial system, the United States Coast Guard, and the New York Post newspaper, he was a significant defender and interpreter of the US Constitution.

One of the American founding fathers is Alexander Hamilton. His list of accomplishments includes shaping the American financial system and aiding in the Revolutionary War's victory over the British. He also succeeded in having the U.S. Constitution passed.

To read more about Alexander Hamilton, refer to - https://brainly.com/question/11819506

#SPJ1

How does Mr. Johnson contribute to making Momma mad?

Answers

We can see here that Mr. Johnson contributes to making Momma mad because he was the one that advised Wilona's husband, Daniel that he can make it straight to Alabama in one shot.

What is The Watsons Go to Birmingham – 1963?

"The Watsons Go to Birmingham – 1963"  is actually known to be a historical-fiction novel by Christopher Paul Curtis. Both adult and young audience members can learn about the reality of racial injustice through the book. It has won numerous important prizes and accolades for its historical racism and themes of familial love.

Momma was upset that they didn't stop in Cincinnati because it derailed all of their plans for the night stay. Mr. Johnson is the friend that gave Daniel advice about the Brown Bomber, and tells him it can make it all the way to Alabama in one shot.

Learn more about The Watsons Go to Birmingham – 1963 on https://brainly.com/question/9098062

#SPJ1

Question 5 of 10
Which question would be most appropriate to ask yourself when considering
how to address your audience for a procedural document?
A. What research do I need to do to understand my topic?
B. Why can't I find a good image to illustrate my points?
C. Where can I go for information about my topic?
O
O D. Will readers respond best to a formal or informal style?
SUBMIT

Answers

Answer:

What research do i need to do to understand my topic

Answer:

A is the answer A is the answer

HURRY I NEED THIS NOW!!! (imma type it if you can’t see clearly)
What is the central idea of this passage?
A. The pigs are natural card players.
B. The animals outside want to come inside too.
C. Napoleon is the leader of the pigs and humans.
D. The pigs are socializing with humans and behaving like them.

Answers

The central idea of the passage is:

D. The pigs are socializing with humans and behaving like them.

From the excerpt, we discover that the writer reveals that "The pigs appeared completely at ease in their chairs" when "Napoleon himself occupying the seat of honour at the head of the table" . This depicts that the pigs were socializing with humans.

Napoleon is seen sitting on the same table with the pigs.Napoleon, a human and the pigs doing the same thing reveals that the pigs were doing same thing as the humans.

Learn more about Animal Farm on https://brainly.com/question/13717719


Read the excerpt below:
"Executive functions enable us to plan and coordinate our decisions and actions, and to exert mental flexibility and self-
control. As shown in the case of Phineas Gage, patients with prefrontal cortex damage find it difficult to plan-whether it
planning what they're going to do today, next week or next year:

What impact does diction and syntax have on the above passage? How does it contribute to the author's purpose? Use
specific examples of each.

Answers

Answer: The phrase “executive function” refers to a set of skills. These skills underlie the capacity to plan ahead and meet goals, display self-control, follow multiple-step directions even when interrupted, and stay focused despite distractions, among others.

Explanation:

This is one of the questions I have please soemone help “ why do u think Macbeth wanted to be queen and why do killing the only way and why do u think she feels guilty explain her answer with evidence “

Answers

Answer:

Lady MacBeth lived in a male-dominated society. The only two ways a woman could move up in the world was 1) by marrying a man who was more wealthy or came from a higher social class or 2) if her husband moved up in the world. I imagine she believed that by convincing her husband to kill Duncan and thus becoming queen - she would have all the validation she ever wanted, and have more power/control in her life (something nearly all human being crave). Note, she also may have been thinking about how much better her children’s lives would be if they were royalty….of course that didn’t work out.

HELP ME ON THIS, PLEASEE GUYS
1.) The point at which Hamlet realizes that his Uncle is guilty of his father's murder is which stage of development in the drama?

A.) exposition

B.) rising action

C.) climax

D.) falling action

Answers

Answer:

b

Explanation:

The answer is would be C, the climax.

How did the painter both honor Jimmy Lyons specifically and the children of the neighborhood?

Answers

She depicts all the locals, famous figures, and Jimmy's name. The wall, in the narrator's opinion, belonged to the residents of their town, and the painter "had no right" to decorate it.

Most notably, Jimmy Lyons' name is carved into the wall. He belonged to the group of those who went to Vietnam and never came home. When the project is finished, the residents of the area will have something to be proud of. In honor of community members and Civil Rights activists, the artist has painted a vibrant mural. The painter gives the populace a sense of pride in their culture and neighborhood through her work. An additional inscription on this "Wall of Respect" is a tribute by the artist to her relative Jimmy Lyons. Her dedication to her cousin might also operate as a form of therapy for her when he did not return from the war. Because of these factors, the mural benefits both the neighborhood and the painter.

To know more about painter refer below:

brainly.com/question/28645890

#SPJ4

What's the main point or theme of Mulan?

Answers

Answer:

Honor,family, and respect for elders and duty

Mulan focuses on the themes of misogyny, sexism, and subverting the norm. At every turn, Mulan is fighting against her country's tradition, the expectations of her family, and the mindsets of individuals who have had a very specific idea of what a woman's role is in the world.

In Hamlet's speech to the players, he urges them to act in ways that are __________. unusual and seemingly insane muted and restrained bombastic and over-the-top natural and realistic

Answers

In Hamlet's speech to the players, he urges them to act in ways that are natural and realistic.

Even with all the biographical details that are undoubtedly accessible to us Shakespeare readers, it would be challenging to determine which of these speeches most accurately captures Shakespeare's personal observations on his own life. It would be a strong argument to say that.

Hamlet's advice to the players (in which Hamlet delivers what we can assume is Shakespeare's understanding of the art and craft of being an actor on stage, and perhaps in life, too) reflects best upon Shakespeare's own life because Shakespeare is best known for being the greatest playwright to have ever lived and because he himself was an actor and because both occupations took up most of his active life, as we know it.

To know more about Hamlet visit:

https://brainly.com/question/11165892

#SPJ4

need ace. to help me plssss ​

Answers

Answer:

3. is the answer

hope this helps

have a good day :)

Explanation:

Answer:

3

Explanation:

have a good day and can you let me know if it is right

diary entry an old village home

Answers

Answer: June 16, 1969,

Today Sunny and I went on a walk into town, I wore my pink lace dress with my new boots. I harnessed Sunny up in her collar and leash and started our 3-mile walk. Mama sent me to get some flour so she can make some muffins.

Explanation: Hope this helps!

(Just a little start hopefully you like it) Its okay if not

‼️‼️‼️PLEASE HELP
Will give BRAINLIEST!!!!

Answers

Answer:

A.

Explanation:

Answer:

Explanation:

The correct Answer is A 100%

Question & story are below! :D

Answers

Answer:

The neighborhood around Zebras school seemed as if it was in the suburbs. It is strangely empty as stated in the last paragraph. The neighborhood didn't have people nor traffic. It didn't even have stray dogs that would just roam about. It seemed "vacant and silent as if it were already in the full heat of summer." You can see some of the teachers houses such as Mr. Morgans and Mrs. English. The other homes on the street had columned front porches and back patios. Their houses and oak trees stood curiously still in the warm golden light of the midmorning sun. That's why the neighborhood around the school seem as if they were suburbs or really nice and quiet people lived there.

Select the correct answer.
When evaluating an argument, what can tone reveal to a reader?
A.
the feeling of the general public about the issue
OB.
the author's use of language
oc.
the author's purpose
D.
the author's blas
Reset
Next

Answers

Answer:

A: The feeling of the general public about the issue.

Explanation:

Think of it as if you are arguing with a friend or sibling: your tone would want to express your feeling about the situation: high and unstable: they are sad, etc, etc.

The feeling of the general public about the issue.

What does it mean to evaluate an argument?

An argument is an end based totally upon evidence (i.e. premises). Arguments are generally discovered in newspaper editorials and opinion columns, as well as magazine essays. To evaluate these arguments, you must decide whether it is ideal or awful.

How do you evaluate an argument in a text?

Identify and analyze the claim. Evaluate the reasons. Critique the evidence. Weigh counterclaims.

Learn more about the argument here https://brainly.com/question/3775579

#SPJ2

What is the most striking lesson you learn from the journey of Gilgamesh?

Answers

The Gilgamesh Epic's fundamental takeaway is that death cannot be stopped. Gilgamesh spends a great deal of time and energy looking for eternal life.

Benjamin Foster recounts an old Mesopotamian tale of a ruler who gains wisdom through tragedy in The Epic of Gilgamesh. Gilgamesh discovers that even he, the great Gilgamesh, cannot achieve immortality while searching for it in order to maintain his tremendous strength and power. Along the journey, he also loses a close companion.

Gilgamesh abandons his loved ones and departs for a desert sojourn in search of an unattainable goal. After trying to become immortal, he makes an effort to utilize magic to stay young, but he too fails at it.

To know more about the Central Idea of the story, refer to this link:

https://brainly.com/question/8282081

#SPJ4

Finish the story
In the distance, I saw a shimmering light...

250 words


please help!!! I need this done quick!!!!

Answers

Answer:

I hope this helps, and you can make any changes to the storyline that you want. Thanks, and I hope this helps! Tell me what you think! BRAINLIEST PLEASE!

Explanation:

In the distance, I saw a shimmering light. The light was glistening off something metallic in the distance. From what I could see from my makeshift shelter, something must be coming to shore. I have been trapped on this desolate island for weeks, and I have long lost hope in someone finding me. Maybe today was the day, I might be saved. Maybe that light I saw was a ship coming toward my island, it might be the sun glistening off the hull of a steamship.  

  I jumped up, the hope bubbling once more in my veins, the happiness rising within me. I was going to go home, home to America, where I would have a warm bed, no more eating bugs and animals that I could trap. I could sit down to an actual meal, like Mcdonald's, or go get a coffee in the mornings at the local cafe. I could be almost human again, I could go back to having first-world problems instead of living like a savage dog in the wilderness.  

 I looked around my desolate shelter, seeing what I should pack. There wasn't anything I wanted to bring with me. I wanted to leave this desolate place behind, and everything that would remind me of it. I wanted to forget this experience had ever happened, even though I knew in the back of my mind that I would never be able to forget the horrors of being stranded on this island.  

 I only grabbed what I was able to salvage from my shipwreck, a compass, my wrist-watch, which didn't even work anymore, and the jacket I had been wearing when I was stranded. Of course, now it was also ruined, thread-bare and tattered, but it was one of the only things that had survived the wreck, and so I had to bring it with me.  

 As I made my way down the beach, I saw the ship coming towards shore. They must have seen the shelter I made in the trees. I had kept a fire burning for the many weeks I was here. Even though I had lost hope, in the back of my mind I wanted to at least try to get someone to see me. I looked back towards the trees and looked along the shoreline. The palms swayed gently, and the sand was white and beautiful. If I wouldn't have been stranded and fighting for my life, I would have thought this island was beautiful, and a place I would love to visit.  

  "Hello down there!" A man called from the ship, and he waved down to me. "Let down a rope for the young man!"  

  A rope was thrown down, and they hauled me up to the ship. They looked at me in wonder, and I knew why. I was dressed in skins I had collected and sewn together with my bare hands, and my beard was long and shaggy. I was, of course, dirty, I hadn't wanted to have soap or anything to clean with really, and I must have been disgusting smelling, but the joy of being found was too overwhelming to be embarrassed by it. I was going home.  

What is MOST likely the reason that creative writers frequently overlook clarity issues in their texts as they are proofreading them?
A.
Creative writers are generally fueled by emotion and sentiment rather than logic and precision.
B.
Creative writers are burdened by the knowledge of what they intended to write.
C.
The proofreading phase of editing is meant to catch grammatical issues rather than issues with clarity.
D.
Creative writers focus too much on what the reader will think of the text and thus miss clarity issues.

Answers

Creative writers are burdened by the knowledge of what they intended to write is MOST likely the reason that creative writers frequently overlook clarity issues in their texts as they are proofreading them. Hence, option B is correct.

What is  Creative writers?

Creative writers produce non-fictional works including essays, biographies, and articles as well as fiction such as short stories, plays, novels, and poetry. Generally speaking, they: Investigate periodicals, such as magazines, to which they would like to submit their writing, especially non-fiction.

Despite the fact that some people are naturally gifted writers, anyone can acquire the craft of creative writing if they put in the necessary time and effort.

The lesson for all authors is that we can all get better and that we are not constrained by a certain amount of innate writing ability. Writing talent cannot be inherited. They've been taught.

Thus, option B is correct.

For more information about Creative writers, click here:

https://brainly.com/question/27925081

#SPJ1

Write a story based on the title of your favorite song. school appropriate

Answers

Answer:

chug jug with you

Explanation:

i drink water so much to the point where i cause a heat wave everwhere and no water exists anywhere

e. a
2. Write True or False.
pointing
a. We can watch movies on a computer.
b. We cannot play games on a computer.
c. The mouse has only one button.
d. Machines save our time and energy.
e. Monitor look like a television.
3. Match the following
a. Play
b. Draw
c. Write​

Answers

Answer:

true false false true true

How are the Galapagos finches an example of natural selection?

Answers

Until all of them split off to become distinct species, Darwin's Finches' beneficial adaptations were chosen for over many generations.

What did Darwin have had to say regarding finch beaks?

Fitzgerald's Finches: Darwin remarked that the beak morphologies of various finch species vary. He suggested that the beak of an ancestral species had changed over time to allow finches to utilise a range of food sources.

What does Darwin's finches explain?

Since they provided some of the early understandings of biological evolution and adaptive radiation, the Galápagos finch that belonging to Charles Darwin are historically significant in the study of evolution.

To learn more about Darwin's Finches' beaks, visit:

brainly.com/question/2047819

#SPJ4

Review isaac’s research assignment and presentation plan. then choose the correct way to complete the sentences. this presentation format is inappropriate for isaac’s . he can correct this by_____ .

Answers

Go over Isaac's research plan and presentation. then decide how to finish the phrases in the appropriate manner. This style of presentation is improper for Isaac. He can provide a more thorough presentation to correct this.

A presentation enables a speaker to inform an audience. Presentations are often demonstrations, advice, lectures, or speeches used to educate, convince, inspire, motivate, foster goodwill, or introduce novel concepts or products.

The act of presenting involves explaining a subject to an audience. This usually involves a demonstration, presentation, lecture, or speech that aims to educate, convince, inspire, motivate, foster goodwill, or introduce a novel concept or item.

Learn more about presentation Visit: brainly.com/question/25703682

#SPJ4

"Of Mice and Men" Chapters 5-6 word puzzle

Answers

Of Mice and Men is a novella written by John Steinbeck.

What is the Of Mice and Men?

Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is a tale about what it means to be human. The story of George and Lennie's desire to own their own ranch and the challenges they face in realizing that desire by Steinbeck illustrates the nature of dreams, dignity, loneliness, and sacrifice.

Profanity, dismal and depressing themes, and the author's supposed "anti-business stance" have all been criticized. It has been criticized by others for being "derogatory against African Americans, women, as well as the developmentally challenged."

Learn more about Of Mice and Men here:

https://brainly.com/question/11853749

#SPJ1

Other Questions
Money has evolved over time frombeing printed on valuable substances (commodity money) to merely representing those valuable substances (commodity-backed money) to not representing anything at all (fiat money). The values of both fiat money and commodity money are determined by supply and demand. They both require faith that you will be able to spend them tomorrow. So, they are both the same in that respect. The only difference between fat and commodities is that the fiat is issued by a government, and the government can issue as much as it wants. Some people are worried about our economy because the government can print as much fiat money as it wants. However, the amount of gold and silver can't just be produced just like that, their value is derived by demand and supply where supply can't be unlimited unlike Fiat money. Do you agree or disagree with this concept? Explain your answer. What is the decimal equivalent of 15/8 How does a free enterprise system provide opportunities for individuals? Marcy made a lane change when. A car was in her side mirror blind spot. She missed the car but immediately crashed into the car ahead of her, causing damage. After Marcy filed the insurance claim, she was notified that her premium for full insurance would increase by 35% what is Marcy new yearly premium if her premium before the accident was $2,140Peter insurance company is raising his rates after he files a claim . He pays $75 per month and his insurance is set to increase by 30% . What will Peters new monthly premium be ? Kevin purchases a truck for $35,000 with a down payment of $4,300 . The monthly payment factor is 0.01933. What is the monthly payment for the truck ? What is a quotation and give two examples? After embracing a BYOD policy, a company is faced with new security challenges from unmanaged mobile devices and laptops. The companys IT department has seen a large number of the following incidents: Duplicate IP addresses Rogue network devices Infected systems probing the companys networkWhich of the following should be implemented to remediate the above issues? (Choose two.)A. Port securityB. Route protectionC. NACD. HIPSE. NIDS A 13.1-g sample of ice at 17.9C is mixed with 103.5 g of water at 73.0C. Calculate the final temperature of the mixture assuming no heat loss to the surroundings. The heat capacities of H2O(s) and H2O(l) are 2.03 and 4.18 J/gC, respectively, and the enthalpy of fusion for ice is 6.02 kJ/mol. What is described: Blood type ABpls help me i need to finish this biology test tonight 11. - a? - 2bc - Iclif a = -2, b = 3,and c = -3problem in the photo algebra The box plot below shows the total amount of time, in minutes, the students of a class surf the Internet every day:A box plot is shown. The left-most point on the plot is 20 and the right-most point is 95. The box is labeled 40 on the left edge and 60 on the right edge. A vertical line is drawn inside the rectangle at the point 50.Part A: List two pieces of information that are provided by the graph and one piece of information that is not provided by the graph. (4 points)Part B: Calculate the interquartile range of the data, and explain in a sentence or two what it represents. (4 points)Part C: Explain what affect, if any, there will be if an outlier is present. (2 points) find the cube root of 512 PleaseeeTrue or False?a) a line contains 2 pointsb) a plane does not contain 3pts not all one linec) Through any 2 points, exactly 1 line existsd) If 2 planes intersect, their intersection is a point How does Claudius feel in Act 3? Type the correct answer in each box. Sharon tracks the number of cupcakes she sells each day for a week. The numbers of cupcakes she sold are 23, 25, 32, 35, 36, 25, and 27. The mean of her sales over the week is , and the median is . Reset Next Why do some elements not take part in chemical bonds? Almost all of the oxygen (O2) one consumes in breathing is converted to:a. acetyl-CoA.b. carbon dioxide (CO2).c. carbon monoxide and then to carbon dioxide.d. none of the above.e. water. The triangle below is a right triangle. What is the length of the missing side? Round your answer to the nearest whole number? A. 7 inchesB. 11 inchesC. 15 inchesD. 225 inches Please help! Worth 20 points and Ill give brainliest. What is the significance of the phrase knot it in the final lines of the play? Pls answer! this problem